Tom Cillo walked onto the practice field at Lycoming College for the first time and found himself lined up against players 40 years younger and 40 pounds heavier. He was wearing a helmet for only the second time in his life. The first time, he was a high school freshman who quit after a couple of days of training camp. That was 1980. He was 15 years old.
In 2025, he was 58. He had no interest in quitting again.
Cillo, a retired city worker from Williamsport, Pennsylvania, enrolled as a freshman at Lycoming College, a Division III liberal arts school. He played nose tackle on the football team and majored in criminal justice. He was four years older than his head coach. Every one of his three children was older than any of his teammates. He draws a pension from a job he held for 33 years with Williamsport’s streets and parks department. He will be eligible for Social Security before his junior year. When the whistle blows, none of that matters.
“It’s a little more challenging than what I had anticipated,” he told reporters, “and I didn’t come into this naive. Whether you’re 18 or 58, you better have a little bit of crazy in you to step out on this field.”
What took 40 years to happen?
Earlier in 2025, Cillo was catching up with his longtime friend Dave Bellomo, a trainer he had known since the 1990s. The conversation drifted to regrets. Having never attended college, Cillo had always wanted a shot at Lycoming, his hometown school. Not going to college was one regret. Never really playing football was another. Bellomo’s response was simple: why not now?
Cillo enrolled full-time at Lycoming after leaving a maintenance role at his alma mater, Williamsport Area High School, where he had worked since retiring from the city’s streets and parks department. He had spent those months working alongside student athletes every day, watching them compete. In September 2025, he signed a name, image, and likeness deal with Aspercreme, making him the oldest college football player to sign an NIL deal.
As part of the partnership, Cillo received a four-year supply of Aspercreme. The brand’s news release noted that it was enough to carry him through every snap, sprint, and sore muscle until graduation. It was also Aspercreme’s first NIL deal.
Read More: A Fitness Coach Says These 4 Habits Are Key to Keeping Your Muscle as You Age
What road led him here?
In 2024, Cillo broke the International Powerlifting Association world record in the deadlift for the 55-59 age group, lifting 580 pounds. He has been powerlifting for over 20 years. That physical foundation, built across two decades of powerlifting, Strongman events, marathons, and triathlons, is what made the football dream viable. Strength was never going to be the obstacle.
The harder story is what came before all of it. Cillo had wanted to play college football when he graduated high school, but that path was pushed aside due to his struggles with drug addiction. He found his way out through work and the weight room. He stopped recreational drug use in his early 20s and left heavy drinking behind in his 30s. He replaced those habits with a consistent drive to test himself physically.
The path to the roster ran through a contact. Mark Sitler, a member of the Lycoming College Board of Trustees and a friend of Cillo’s for 25 years, introduced him to head coach Mike Clark. Clark received a message explaining Cillo’s interest in trying out. He gave him a chance based largely on his commitment and weight-room ability. Clark, 54, has built Lycoming into a consistent contender over nearly two decades on the sideline.
What did game day look like at 58?
On September 28, 2025, Cillo made his college football debut in a junior varsity game against King’s College. Lycoming won 23-16. Cillo, listed at 6-foot-2 and 220 pounds, lined up in the trenches against players who were born decades after he graduated high school.
Before the season, he told WNEP TV: “I thought, I’m going to give this a shot and I’m going to write the script.” He also said, “I know people are going to think I’m crazy, and think that I’m out of my mind to do something like this at 58 years old.” The reactions he has received, from teammates, opponents, and strangers around the country, have been almost universally the opposite of what he feared.
The NCAA record still belongs to someone else. At 61, Tom Thompson became the oldest football player in NCAA history when he kicked a point after touchdown in the second quarter of a game between Austin College and Trinity University on November 14, 2009. Before that game, Thompson had last played organized football nearly 50 years earlier in high school. His Austin College jersey is part of the College Football Hall of Fame’s collection. Cillo, at 58, was three years younger than Thompson was. The record is still out there.
What does “now or never” actually look like?
Regret was the word Cillo kept coming back to in the months before he enrolled. He had not gone to college. He had not played football. He had the sense that decades had passed and those doors had quietly closed without him ever trying them. His decision to enroll was not, he has stressed, about being reckless. It was about being honest.
“It was time to put regret, not even in the rearview mirror, but time to put it out of sight,” he said. “Rearview mirror means you can still see it. I wanted it out of the picture altogether. It was time. It was now or never.”
Cillo never played organized football before becoming a 58-year-old freshman defensive lineman. Most older players who have appeared in college football games came to the sport as kickers or specialists, positions that reward precision over athleticism and carry lower collision risk. Cillo plays in the trenches. At nose tackle, he lines up in the middle of every run play, absorbing contact from linemen who outweigh him, keeping his footing, and reading formations he only recently started learning.
In a statement tied to his Aspercreme deal, Cillo said: “At 58, I’m still lacing up, competing, and showing that passion doesn’t age.”
His three children, stepson Shawn, 32, daughter Nicole, 28, and son Ryan, 21, are all older than Cillo’s teammates. His wife Ana, who has known her husband to sign up for marathons, triathlons, and powerlifting world records with equal enthusiasm, was wary but supportive.
What does this mean for you?
Cillo’s story is not an instruction manual. Most 58-year-olds are not going to walk onto a college football roster, nor should they try. What his case shows is more specific. A person can mistake the absence of action for the closing of an option. Cillo spent four decades carrying a pair of regrets that were, in practical terms, still open to him. It took a friend asking a simple question, “why don’t you?”, to bring that fact to the surface.
The foundation he built over those same decades mattered enormously. More than 20 years of powerlifting, years without drugs or alcohol, and a consistent competitive drive applied to whatever challenge was in front of him were not wasted. Consistency in the decades before a midlife risk is what determines whether the risk is reckless or reasonable. Cillo earned his shot at 58 by the choices he made at 28 and 38.
His words after his debut, still wearing his jersey in the locker room at Girardi Stadium, say it plainly: “Now that I’ve got some actual game reps, it’s going to keep building. I can’t wait.” He had waited long enough.
Editor’s note: The headline describes a 58-year-old Pennsylvania man who is tackling his dream of playing college football. Tom Cillo walked onto Lycoming College’s team as a 58-year-old freshman in 2025. He has since entered his sophomore season and is now 59.
Disclaimer: The author is not a licensed medical professional. The information provided is for general informational and educational purposes only and is based on research from publicly available, reputable sources. It is not intended to constitute, and should not be relied upon as, medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a licensed physician or other qualified healthcare provider regarding any medical condition, symptoms, or medications. Do not disregard, avoid, or delay seeking professional medical advice or treatment because of information contained herein.
AI Disclaimer: This article was created with the assistance of AI tools and reviewed by a human editor.