From a niche topic to an entire movement, the debate over seed oils versus animal fats among wellness fanatics has gone full swing on social media, with many demonising certain seed oils and glorifying the adoption of animal fats like butter and lard. This shift comes just two decades after the fat-free craze of the early 2000s, leaving many confused about which type of fat is healthier. At the heart of this controversy are claims that seed oils are “toxic” or contribute to chronic diseases. However, all of these claims lack any scientific backing.
Understanding Seed Oils
People extract seed oils from the seeds of plants. Common examples include canola oil, soybean oil, sunflower oil, corn oil, safflower oil, sesame oil, cottonseed oil, and grapeseed oil. These oils are rich in unsaturated fats, which are beneficial for health, particularly in lowering LDL cholesterol and reducing the risk of heart disease.
The extraction process for seed oils typically involves crushing the seeds to release the oil, followed by chemical extraction using solvents to separate the oil from the seeds. After extraction, most seed oils undergo refinement to remove impurities, enhance flavour, extend shelf life, and improve heat stability.Refinement reduces some nutrients but makes the oil more stable and less prone to oxidation, which produces harmful free radicals.
Health Benefits of Seed Oils
Seed oils are generally high in polyunsaturated and monounsaturated fats, which are considered “good” fats. These unsaturated fats help lower LDL “bad” cholesterol and boost HDL “good” cholesterol, protecting against heart disease and stroke. Seed oils are rich in Omega-6 fatty acids and contain small amounts of omega-3. While omega-6s are sometimes linked to inflammation, they also play an important role in immune responses and healing.
The American Heart Association supports the inclusion of omega-6 fatty acids in a healthy diet, emphasizing their heart-healthy benefits when they replace saturated fats. However its important to make sure you getting other essential fatty acids in your diet like omega-3’s. Omega-3s are mainly found in fish and nuts, and the typical American diet is high in omega-6s due to the high comsumption of ultra-processed foods.
Controversy Surrounding Seed Oils
Critics of seed oils often state that seed oils’ high omega-6 content and the refining process involved in their production make them “toxic”. Some argue that these are the reasons to actively avoid them. However, this lacks any sound scientific evidence to support this claim. While seed oils are rich in omega-6 unsaturated fatty acids, the risk of increasing inflammation is only of concern when a person doesn’t receive enough anti-inflammatory omega-3 acids. The idea that someone need to limit their omega 6 intake and maintain a proper omaga 6 to 3 ratio isn’t supported by evidence. While mechenistic data may suppurt the idea of maintaining a proper ratio, human trials do not. Health experts link the presence of seed oils in ultra-processed foods to poor health and issues like heart conditions, which is the real concern.
Understanding Animal Fats
People derive animal fats from animals, which include butter, beef tallow, lard, chicken fat, and duck fat. These fats are mainly saturated, and consuming them in excess raises LDL cholesterol and increases the risk of heart disease. Manufacturers often make animal fats by heating them to liquefy and separate them from meat, and they may refine some to enhance their color, flavor, smell, and remove impurities. They are usually solid at room temperature and some animal fats can contain trace amounts of monounsaturated fats.
Read More: This ‘Healthy Oil’ May Be Increasing Your Cholesterol and Dementia Risk
Health Considerations of Animal Fats
While animal fats are not considered “superfoods,” they can be part of a healthy diet when consumed in moderation. They are an energy abundant source and rich in fat-soluble vitamins like A, D, and E. However, the high saturated fat content in animal fats can lead to increased LDL cholesterol levels and contribute to heart disease. The American Heart Association recommends limiting saturated fat intake to less than 6% of total daily calories.
Cultural and Culinary Significance of Animal Fats
People add cultural and culinary significance to dishes using animal fats, which flavor food and reduce waste by utilizing parts of the animal that might otherwise thrown away. Experts recommend choosing minimally processed fats from grass-fed, pasture-raised animals when using animal fats. For example, grass-fed butter contains higher levels of heart-healthy omega-3 fatty acids and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), which reduces the risk of heart disease and cancer.
Comparing Seed Oils and Animal Fats
When comparing seed oils and animal fats, it’s essential to consider their nutritional profiles and health impacts. Seed oils are generally healthier due to their high unsaturated fat content, which supports heart health by lowering LDL cholesterol and reducing the risk of heart disease. In contrast, animal fats are primarily saturated, which can increase LDL cholesterol and contribute to cardiovascular issues when consumed excessively.
The “Hateful Eight” and Misconceptions
The term “Hateful Eight” refers to a list of seed oils, including canola and corn oil, that some advocate avoiding. Critics claim these oils are harmful due to their omega-6 content and processing methods. Experts emphasize that seed oils are not toxic and refute these claims with a lack of scientific evidence.
Scientific Consensus
The scientific consensus is that seed oils, when consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet, are beneficial for health. Replacing saturated fats with unsaturated fats like those found in seed oils can lower the risk of heart disease and stroke. While some studies suggest that swapping animal fats for certain vegetable oils may not always be beneficial, this is more related to the specific types of oils used and the overall dietary choices rather than shunning all seed oils.
Practical Recommendations
Substitute seed oils for saturated fats like butter in cooking, and consume them in moderation as part of a balanced diet. Prioritize whole, nutrient-dense foods over ultra-processed ones, which often contain high amounts of seed oils and other unhealthy ingredients. If opting for animal fats, select minimally processed options from grass-fed animals to maximize nutritional benefits. For cooking, choose oils with high smoke points, such as avocado oil or refined olive oil, to prevent oxidation and maintain the nutritional properties.
Conclusion
The debate between seed oils and animal fats highlights the complexity of dietary fats and the importance of a balanced diet. While seed oils are generally healthier due to their unsaturated fat content, animal fats can also be part of a healthy diet when consumed in moderation. The key is to focus on whole, nutrient rich foods and avoid ultra-processed products, regardless of the type of fat they contain.
Read More: 8 Heart Healthy Supplements To Consider (and 2 To Avoid)