Sean Cate
Sean Cate
April 21, 2024 ·  3 min read

Lawyer shares question you should ‘never answer in a million years’ if you’re pulled over by police

When it comes to interactions with law enforcement officers during a traffic stop, there’s a question that you should never answer without careful consideration. The question, “Do you know why I pulled you over?” might seem innocuous at first, but according to legal expert @tiktokstreetlawyer, it’s a question that drivers should approach with caution. The lawyer emphasizes the importance of not answering this question without knowing the specific suspected offense you’re being accused of.1

This seemingly straightforward query, posed by police officers during traffic stops, could be a trick designed to catch drivers off guard. By not knowing the offense in question, answering this question prematurely could lead to unintended self-incrimination. @tiktokstreetlawyer advises drivers to refrain from guessing the correct response, unless they possess the ability of a “Jedi mind reader.” Instead, the best course of action is to avoid answering altogether and to politely ask the officer for clarification on the reason for the stop.

Knowing Your Rights as a Driver

Understanding your rights as a driver or passenger during a traffic stop is crucial to safeguarding yourself from potential legal troubles. It’s important to recognize that certain protections apply to individuals stopped by law enforcement officers. These rights can vary by state laws and specific circumstances, but you don’t have to be a lawyer to know them.2

Key rights include:

Waiting for Safety

If it’s not safe to pull over immediately, you have the right to find a secure location before stopping.

Reasonable Suspicion

Officers require reasonable suspicion to initiate a traffic stop.

Remaining Silent

You have the Fifth Amendment right to stay silent and not answer questions from law enforcement. You can wait until a lawyer is present before saying anything to anyone else.

Refusing Roadside Tests

You can decline to take a roadside breathalyzer test, which may have consequences depending on your state.

Recording Encounters

You’re generally allowed to record encounters with police.

Probable Cause for Searches

Police need probable cause to search your vehicle.

Remember that laws surrounding traffic stops can vary by state, and understanding these rights can potentially save you time, money, and legal complications.

Navigating Law Enforcement Questions

Navigating questions from law enforcement officers can be a delicate process, and it’s important to be aware of your rights in various situations. Whether you’re pulled over by state or local police officers, members of the Joint Terrorism Task Force, or federal agents, understanding your rights is essential.3

One important aspect is your right to remain silent. You are not obligated to answer questions posed by law enforcement officers, even if you’re not free to leave, under arrest, or in custody. It’s generally recommended to consult with a lawyer before answering any questions. In certain situations, you may be required to provide your name, but this doesn’t mean you have to answer other questions.

If you choose to speak with law enforcement, be mindful that anything you say can be used against you. It’s essential to exercise your right to remain silent until you’ve had the chance to consult with a lawyer. Additionally, if an officer threatens you with a grand jury subpoena, you can still decline to answer questions right away and seek legal advice.

In situations like “counter-terrorism interviews,” you have the right to set conditions for the interview, such as having an attorney present, knowing the questions beforehand, and answering only those questions you’re comfortable with. Always remember that honesty is important, and knowingly lying to an officer can result in legal consequences.

Navigating Police Interactions with Confidence

Understanding your rights and how to handle questions from law enforcement officers during traffic stops is essential for protecting yourself from unintended self-incrimination. As shown by our online lawyer friend, a seemingly innocuous question, “Do you know why I pulled you over?” can have significant legal implications. By staying informed about your rights, remaining calm, and seeking legal advice when necessary, you can navigate these interactions with confidence and make informed decisions that safeguard your legal interests.


How to answer this police question- “why do you think i pullled you over?” #streetlawyer #communitylegaleducation #police #traffic #question #fyp

♬ original sound – Street Lawyer


  1. Lawyer shares question you should ‘never answer’ if pulled over by police.” JOE. Charlie Herbert. August 16, 2023.
  2. What are my rights if I’m pulled over by a cop?Finder. Roslyn McKenna. March 24, 2022.
  3. “KNOW YOUR RIGHTS What To Do When Encountering Questions from Law Enforcement.” ACLU