Product recalls are a common part of maintaining safety standards, but every now and then, one comes along that stands out for its unusual or unexpected nature. Recently, Costco was forced to issue a recall for butter for the most ridiculous reason, sparking both confusion and plenty of online chatter. What initially seemed like a routine announcement quickly turned into a topic of widespread discussion—and humor.
The Dairy Dilemma
The recall, initiated by the FDA, impacted 79,200 pounds of Kirkland Signature butter, including both the salted and unsalted Sweet Cream Butter varieties. While the product listed cream as an ingredient, the packaging didn’t include a specific allergen statement warning that it “contains milk”.
This oversight led the FDA to classify the recall as Class II, meaning it could cause “temporary or medically reversible adverse health consequences”. While this classification reflects the potential risks for those with severe milk allergies, the recall sparked a wave of sarcastic comments online.
Social Media’s Response: “It’s Butter”
The internet was quick to weigh in, with many mocking the recall. One user quipped, “Next they’ll recall beef that might contain cow”. Another joked, “Can y’all please safely dispose of it at my house? I have a lot of holiday baking to do”.
Kristen Meg, a social media user, expressed a mix of sympathy and exasperation: “As someone with serious dietary restrictions, I have to say…this is pretty ridiculous. We all know butter contains milk”.
Others took aim at the government’s involvement, with one commenter lamenting, “Talk about useless government. To be called ‘butter,’ it must contain milk”.
Food Safety and Waste Concerns
Despite the humor, the situation highlights a serious issue for individuals with allergies, as even trace amounts of allergens can cause severe reactions. However, some critics questioned the wastefulness of recalling perfectly good food. One user suggested, “Why don’t they print stickers that say ‘Contains Milk’ and save perfectly good food?”.
As the recall unfolded, Costco and the FDA didn’t report any allergic reactions linked to the mislabeled butter. Still, the incident underscores the importance of clear labeling while also reminding everyone of the absurdity in needing to clarify the obvious.
Read More: Cheese Sold at Market Basket, Aldi, and More Recalled Due to Listeria Contamination